Ingvar Jónsson

Writing

Essays on self-knowledge, leadership and being human in a changing world. Click the plus to open an essay and its illustration. Most end with a micro-action: one small step you can try straight away.

17 essays

Illustration: The difference between SMART and BE SMART is the difference between a dream and reality
The old SMART method hands you rulers, ladders and a heavy hourglass to push up the slope, but forgets the one thing that gets the crane moving. Without a clear benefit on the horizon and the heart pulling on the rope down in the corner, goal setting is just a mechanical exercise on paper.

I have sat through countless strategy meetings where managers proudly present their new goals. They are usually bulletproof by the good old SMART formula: specific, measurable, realistic and time-bound. Everything fits perfectly into the spreadsheet. And yet, surprisingly often, three months later nobody is talking about those goals any more. They lie untouched in a drawer, like an expensive gym card bought in January.

The reason is simple: SMART is an outdated method when it comes to moving people. It works fine if you are ordering office supplies or laying asphalt, but it assumes we are robots driven by yardsticks and timeframes. It completely forgets to ask why on earth we should care at all.

When I look at this picture of BE SMART, I see exactly what is missing from the old recipe. All the steelwork in the middle – the ladder, the rulers and that enormous hourglass some poor soul has to push up the slope – is just cold machinery. If you don't add B for Benefits and E for Emotional Leverage, you are just climbing a ladder into thin air and hoping for the best.

The benefit is the lighthouse up in the clouds under the rainbow – a clear picture of how life or work changes for the better when you reach the destination. But even the most beautiful lighthouse will not move the crane. Look at the bottom right corner of the picture. There stands the heart, leaning back with every ounce of strength it has and pulling on the rope. It is the only force that can lift the boom.

Logic makes us nod along in a meeting, but it is emotion – either the anticipation of the win or the fear of staying stuck in the same rut – that gets us to show up on a grey Tuesday morning when nobody is watching. How many goals have you set in your life that looked perfect on paper but never made your heart beat one beat faster?

So the difference between SMART and BE SMART is not just two extra letters. It is the difference between success and failure. Without a benefit you can feel in your gut and an emotional drive pulling on the rope, all you have is a well-worded wish list that you will eventually let yourself down on.

Micro-action

Find the rope on the crane

Take one goal you are working on right now but feel yourself starting to drag your feet on. Put all yardsticks and timelines aside for five minutes. Write down your answers to two questions:

1.What is the real benefit (B)? What actually changes in my life, or in other people's lives, if this succeeds?

2.What will it cost me emotionally (E) if I don't do this? How will I feel if things are exactly the same a year from now?

If the answers don't move you, throw the goal away and find one that does.

One question a week

Your life is your work of art. Get one question a week to reflect on.